DIY Custom Pens: A Quick & Easy Tutorial

Hey friends, Allie from AllieScraps here to share a fun, budget-friendly project that adds a color to your everyday pens! Today I’m showing you how to turn ordinary pens into custom creations using scrapbook paper. These make perfect gifts, teacher treats, or just a little happy for your own desk.

What You’ll Need

I used the Amber Glow collection for these newest pens, but I’ve used Jack & Skelly in the past -- any of Traci’s amazing kits would work well!

Check out the video below to see how I do it, or keep reading for the steps!

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Take the Pen Apart

Unscrew the barrel and cap of your pen and pull out the ink refill.

Step 2: Cut Your Paper

Cut your scrapbook paper into narrow strips—slightly longer than the barrel of the pen. It’s okay if they’re a little too long; you’ll trim later.

Step 3: Roll the Paper

Using the pen refill as a guide, tightly roll your strip of paper around it. Roll diagonally at first to get a snug fit, then straighten it out. The tighter the roll, the smoother it will fit into the pen.

Step 4: Insert Into the Barrel

Slip your rolled paper into the clear barrel of the pen. Rotate it so any seam is hidden.
Step 5: Trim the Extra

If a bit of paper is sticking out, gently pull it back, trim with scissors, and slide it back in for a perfect fit.

Step 6: Reassemble the Pen

Pop the refill back in, screw the pen closed, and you’re done. You now have a one-of-a-kind pen that matches your favorite paper collection.

Extra Tips & Ideas

  • Want to swap papers later? Try rolling your strips around a slim straw first, then sliding that into the barrel for easy paper changes. (Check out this creator for a tutorial. This isn’t MY favorite way to do it, but you might like it better!)

  • Make a matching pen set from one scrapbook collection for a fun coordinating gift. Pair them with handmade cards, notepads, or tags for teachers, coworkers, or friends.

  • Seasonal papers = seasonal pens. Halloween, Christmas, or even back-to-school designs make this project extra versatile.

That’s it—just a few minutes to go from plain pens to colorful, custom creations!